Divided or Shared Destiny? IDAS Lecture Explores Historical Parallels Between Canada–U.S. and Cross-Strait Relations
Date :
2026-11-18
Department :
International Doctoral Program in Asia-Pacific Studies
【Article by IDAS】
Historical comparisons offer valuable insights into how smaller political entities navigate relationships with more powerful neighbors. Against this backdrop, the International Doctoral Program in Asia-Pacific Studies (IDAS) at National Chengchi University (NCCU) hosted a lecture titled “Divided or Shared Destiny? Canada and the United States in Historical Process” on 5 November 2026. The lecture was delivered by Adjunct Research Professor Der-Yuan Wu of Carleton University, Canada, and examined the historical evolution of Canada–U.S. relations and its relevance to understanding contemporary cross-Strait relations.
Dr. Wu opened by placing recent remarks by U.S. President Donald Trump concerning the possible annexation of Canada within the broader historical context of bilateral relations. Rather than viewing such developments as unprecedented, he argued that they reflect longstanding tensions between the two countries. Although geopolitical circumstances have evolved, many of the underlying structural dynamics remain persistent. He emphasized that historical patterns of interaction continue to shape political behavior, even as leadership and the international environment change.
A central theme of the lecture was the comparative experience of Canada and Taiwan in managing relations with significantly more powerful neighbors. To establish the historical context for this comparison, Dr. Wu traced the development of Canada–U.S. relations from the colonial era to the present. He identified the enduring tension between continentalism and Canadian nationalism as a defining feature of Canada's political development. While geographic proximity and economic integration have encouraged closer cooperation with the United States, preserving political autonomy and a distinct national identity has remained central to Canadian political discourse. These competing orientations have also been reflected in domestic partisan politics, with different political movements advocating varying degrees of integration and independence throughout Canada's democratic development.
Dr. Wu also challenged the conventional perception of Canada–U.S. relations as an inherently peaceful and cooperative partnership. He noted that the historical relationship has included episodes of military confrontation, political disagreement, and diplomatic tension, alongside extensive periods of cooperation. This historical experience, he suggested, offers important insights for Taiwan. It illustrates how a comparatively weaker political entity may seek to preserve its autonomy and distinct identity despite significant power asymmetries and deep economic and political interdependence with a more powerful neighbor.
During the open forum, students, faculty members, and guests raised questions about the methodological validity of comparing Canada–U.S. relations with cross-Strait relations. One participant pointed to a fundamental difference in their political contexts: Canada maintains relations with a democratic neighbor, whereas Taiwan faces an authoritarian China. In response, Dr. Wu emphasized that political division and unification should be understood as historical processes rather than predetermined outcomes. He also questioned the assumption that political unity necessarily represents the natural or inevitable endpoint of historical development.
Another question focused on the structural differences between the two cases. While Canada–U.S. relations are primarily bilateral, cross-Strait relations are significantly shaped by U.S. involvement, adding an important trilateral dimension. This distinction prompted further discussion of the methodological challenges of historical comparison and the extent to which insights drawn from one geopolitical context can be applied to another.
Overall, Dr. Wu's lecture highlighted the importance of historical structures, political identity, and domestic agency in shaping relationships characterized by significant power asymmetries. Although the experiences of Canada and Taiwan are not directly analogous, their shared structural characteristics offer a valuable foundation for comparative analysis. The discussion further underscored the importance of recognizing both the similarities and differences between historical cases when applying comparative perspectives to contemporary international relations.
Historical comparisons offer valuable insights into how smaller political entities navigate relationships with more powerful neighbors. Against this backdrop, the International Doctoral Program in Asia-Pacific Studies (IDAS) at National Chengchi University (NCCU) hosted a lecture titled “Divided or Shared Destiny? Canada and the United States in Historical Process” on 5 November 2026. The lecture was delivered by Adjunct Research Professor Der-Yuan Wu of Carleton University, Canada, and examined the historical evolution of Canada–U.S. relations and its relevance to understanding contemporary cross-Strait relations.
Dr. Wu opened by placing recent remarks by U.S. President Donald Trump concerning the possible annexation of Canada within the broader historical context of bilateral relations. Rather than viewing such developments as unprecedented, he argued that they reflect longstanding tensions between the two countries. Although geopolitical circumstances have evolved, many of the underlying structural dynamics remain persistent. He emphasized that historical patterns of interaction continue to shape political behavior, even as leadership and the international environment change.
A central theme of the lecture was the comparative experience of Canada and Taiwan in managing relations with significantly more powerful neighbors. To establish the historical context for this comparison, Dr. Wu traced the development of Canada–U.S. relations from the colonial era to the present. He identified the enduring tension between continentalism and Canadian nationalism as a defining feature of Canada's political development. While geographic proximity and economic integration have encouraged closer cooperation with the United States, preserving political autonomy and a distinct national identity has remained central to Canadian political discourse. These competing orientations have also been reflected in domestic partisan politics, with different political movements advocating varying degrees of integration and independence throughout Canada's democratic development.
Dr. Wu also challenged the conventional perception of Canada–U.S. relations as an inherently peaceful and cooperative partnership. He noted that the historical relationship has included episodes of military confrontation, political disagreement, and diplomatic tension, alongside extensive periods of cooperation. This historical experience, he suggested, offers important insights for Taiwan. It illustrates how a comparatively weaker political entity may seek to preserve its autonomy and distinct identity despite significant power asymmetries and deep economic and political interdependence with a more powerful neighbor.
During the open forum, students, faculty members, and guests raised questions about the methodological validity of comparing Canada–U.S. relations with cross-Strait relations. One participant pointed to a fundamental difference in their political contexts: Canada maintains relations with a democratic neighbor, whereas Taiwan faces an authoritarian China. In response, Dr. Wu emphasized that political division and unification should be understood as historical processes rather than predetermined outcomes. He also questioned the assumption that political unity necessarily represents the natural or inevitable endpoint of historical development.
Another question focused on the structural differences between the two cases. While Canada–U.S. relations are primarily bilateral, cross-Strait relations are significantly shaped by U.S. involvement, adding an important trilateral dimension. This distinction prompted further discussion of the methodological challenges of historical comparison and the extent to which insights drawn from one geopolitical context can be applied to another.
Overall, Dr. Wu's lecture highlighted the importance of historical structures, political identity, and domestic agency in shaping relationships characterized by significant power asymmetries. Although the experiences of Canada and Taiwan are not directly analogous, their shared structural characteristics offer a valuable foundation for comparative analysis. The discussion further underscored the importance of recognizing both the similarities and differences between historical cases when applying comparative perspectives to contemporary international relations.